November 10, 2008

Misconceptions about how Flash CS4 implements 3D

Emanuele commented on Keith Peter's blog:
"The reality is that there very little 3D code inside the player, at least native code. Whenever you export a movie that uses the new “3D” features, you’ll notice that about 13KB of AS3 code is attached to it. This code is responsible for the pseudo 3D rendering using same old tricks used by earlier 3D renderers. You see degradation in rendering because those vector objects are transformed into cached bitmaps and handled as texture over triangles. Bitmap resampling algorithms inside the player are pretty good, but not good enough in several situations like this one. The Flash IDE, however, does a good job by making completely transparent to the user that this 3D manipulation is not native to the player itself but rather to silently attached code."

(here comes the snark)
How then am I able to paste one line of code into FlashDevelop and get a perspective-correct 3D rotation?

myMovieClip['rotationX'] = 60;

And my SWF isn't 13 KB, it's 1 KB. So apparently Flash Player 10 doesn't need any "pseudo 3D tricks". Sorry to be Mr. Snarky McSnarksalot, but saying "3D manipulation is not native to the player itself" is just asking for it.

So what is that extra code injected by Flash CS4 actually doing? If you have ASV, you don't have to guess; you can just decompile the SWF and take a look. You won't find any secret calls to drawTriangles(), or even the word "triangle" anywhere (sorry Keith).

What you will find are fl.motion classes. Remember those from Flash CS3? I wrote those to implement the Copy Motion as AS3 feature. For CS4, Rebecca Sun updated them to support 3D properties like rotationX, etc. What happens is that when a CS4 motion tween uses 3D, all of the tween properties are controlled with the Animator3D class. This includes the simple ones like x and y. However, if you don't use 3D, the tween is implemented with SWF tags as it has been for a decade.

Why the dramatic change in tween implementation when you use 3D? It boils down to Adobe deciding not to define new SWF tags for 3D features. I'm not going to comment here on the pros and cons of that decision. The practical result, though, is that 3D motion must be scripted, whether by you or by IDE-generated code. And apparently it's still the case that a movie clip is controlled either by the timeline (i.e. with SWF tags) or by ActionScript. I remember being surprised by this in Flash 4, when one tellTarget to _xscale would break a timeline tween permanently.

The Animator3D class may look complex, but it's not doing any rendering per se; it's doing motion. The rendering code is merely a few assignments to:


There are a lot of Matrix3D manipulations going on. But they are mainly to convert friendly properties like rotationX to coefficients, and to interpolate between matrices. The Animator and Animator3D classes also have to make all scaling and rotation relative to the transformation point, not the origin. This is trickier than you might think.

I hope this helps explain what's going on with that extra 3D code. The moral of this story could also be a nice tagline for ActionScript Viewer:

ASV: Don't guess what's in your SWF. Know it.

August 26, 2008

New build of FlashDevelop 3 released: Beta 8

Mika says:

This release is long overdue but there were a few issues that we wanted to resolve and then there were summer vacations... :)
There are quite a lot of new features and really nice stability improvements, we hope that all of you enjoy this release!

About FlashDevelop:

* Features
* Screenshots


* New "fullscreen" editor mode
* New common GUI for AS2Api and ASDoc
* SWF exploration shows the frame where definitions are imported

* Fine tuned code completion
* Dynamic syntax highlighting: custom classes get colored like flash classes (MovieClip, Event, etc)
* Completion for package-level declarations and Flash 10's Vector. type
* New generator: Ctrl+Shift+1 on a non-imported type to generate the import
* Go To Declaration (F4) with SWC classes display a generated pseudo-class
* Improved generators

* Tags with ID now appear in outline view and script code completion
* Updated completion (generated using a tool available in SVN)

* Improved MXML projects templates
* New optimized AS3 project template with preloader (no Flex dependencies)
* Templates now include an index.html with swfobject.js

* Now featuring simple PHP completion


* Backup your customized user files: The setting files have changed quite a lot so check before you overwrite the new ones.
* Get Adobe Flex 3 SDK. The free Flex SDK (2 or 3) is required for ActionScript 3 development if you don't use Flash CS3.
* Get the debug Flash player (you need: projector and Active X)
* Java 1.6+ is required for the Flex compiler (ActionScript 3).

:!: If you think the program is good, please donate some money for this project. :!:


Built from rev. 36
Download FlashDevelop 3.0.0 Beta8

A job change for me: joining Club Penguin

After being with the Flash Authoring team for over two years, I've made a change. Adobe is an awesome company to work for, but I was working remotely and found I really needed more face-to-face interaction. Every time I went to San Francisco and worked at Flash HQ I'd have such a great time. Then after a week I'd come back and work in a room by myself for months on end. It got depressing after a while and I eventually realized that socializing at work wasn't just a privilege but a necessity for me. I wasn't ready to relocate so I found a position with Club Penguin, a local (Kelowna, B.C.) company that Disney bought last year. I started last week and already I'm talking to myself less. =)

Club Penguin has another position open right now:

I don't know what Adobe's plans are for my former position, but you can keep an eye on their job postings here:

At Club Penguin I'll be taking on massively multiplayer online game development, an exciting new challenge. I'll also be responsible for mentoring the ActionScripters here, equipping them with the best knowledge, tools and practices for Flash development. I'll be advocating for some of my hobby horses like OOP, TDD and AsUnit, pair programming, refactoring, Agile practices, mtasc and mxmlc, SVN, continuous integration, FlashDevelop and Flex Builder. I love both teaching and creating so this will be a nice blend of the two.